Are you planning a road trip or outdoor adventure and wondering whether to invest in a hard shell or a soft shell roof box? Both options have their own set of benefits, but in this article, we’ll explore why a hard shell roof box may be the better choice for you.
Types of Roof Boxes
There are two main types of roof boxes: hard shell and soft shell. Hard shell roof boxes are made of sturdy, durable materials such as fiberglass or ABS plastic, while soft shell roof boxes are made of fabric such as PVC or nylon. Both types have their own advantages and disadvantages, but we’ll be focusing on the benefits of hard shell roof boxes in this article.
Materials
As mentioned earlier, hard shell roof boxes are made of durable materials such as fiberglass or ABS plastic. This makes them more resistant to wear and tear, and they can withstand harsh weather conditions such as rain, snow, and wind. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, are made of fabric which can be easily torn or damaged.
Installation
Hard shell roof boxes are generally easier to install than soft shell ones. They typically come with a mounting system that can be easily attached to your vehicle’s roof rails. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, require more time and effort to install as they need to be secured tightly to prevent any movement or shifting during transport.
Weight Limit
Hard shell roof boxes have a higher weight limit than soft shell ones. This means you can pack more items without exceeding the weight limit, which is important for ensuring safety on the road. Soft shell roof boxes have a lower weight limit and can only carry a limited amount of weight.
Securing Belongings
Hard shell roof boxes offer better security for your belongings as they come with a locking mechanism. This ensures that your items are safe and secure during transport. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, do not come with a locking mechanism, making them more susceptible to theft.
Aerodynamic Design
Hard shell roof boxes are designed to be more aerodynamic, which reduces wind resistance and improves fuel efficiency. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, are less aerodynamic and can create more wind resistance, which can affect your vehicle’s fuel efficiency.
Legality and Restrictions
Before purchasing a roof box, it’s important to check the legality and restrictions in your area. Hard shell roof boxes are often more compliant with regulations as they are more securely attached to your vehicle’s roof. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, may not meet certain regulations in some areas and may require additional securing measures.
Removal
Hard shell roof boxes can be easily removed from your vehicle when not in use. Soft shell roof boxes, on the other hand, may require more time and effort to remove as they need to be dismantled before they can be stored.
Weather Impact
Hard shell roof boxes are more resistant to harsh weather conditions such as rain, snow, and wind. Soft shell roof boxes may not offer as much protection from the elements, which can damage your items during transport.
Storage Options
Hard shell roof boxes offer more storage options as they are available in a wider range of sizes and shapes. Soft shell roof boxes are generally only available in one or two sizes, limiting your storage options.
Roof Box vs Rack vs Trailer
A hard shell roof box is a better option than a roof rack or a trailer as it provides more protection for your items and is more secure. A roof rack may not offer as much protection from the elements, while a trailer can be more difficult to maneuver on the road.
Measuring for Fit
It’s important to measure your vehicle’s roof and the roof box before making a buying decision. Hard shell roof boxes are available in a wider range of sizes, ensuring a better fit for your vehicle. Soft shell roof boxes are limited in size, which may not fit your vehicle properly.
Accessories
Hard shell roof boxes offer a wider range of accessories such as roof racks and mounting systems. Soft shell roof boxes may not offer as many accessories, limiting your options for customization.
Packing Tips
When packing your roof box, it’s important to distribute the weight evenly and to secure your items tightly. Hard shell roof boxes provide more secure packing options, while soft shell roof boxes may not be as secure.
Weight Distribution
Proper weight distribution is important for safety on the road. Hard shell roof boxes have a higher weight limit and can distribute weight more evenly, while soft shell roof boxes have a lower weight limit and may not distribute weight as evenly.
Safety Considerations
When using a roof box, it’s important to follow safety guidelines such as securing the roof box tightly and ensuring proper weight distribution. Hard shell roof boxes offer more secure options for safety, while soft shell roof boxes may require more effort to ensure safety.
Loading and Unloading
Loading and unloading your roof box can be a challenge, but hard shell roof boxes are generally easier to load and unload than soft shell ones. This is because they offer a wider opening and a more secure locking mechanism.
Sizes and Recommended Uses
Hard shell roof boxes are available in a wider range of sizes and are recommended for a variety of uses such as outdoor adventures, family vacations, and business trips. Soft shell roof boxes are limited in size and may not be recommended for certain uses.
Benefits for Outdoor Enthusiasts
Hard shell roof boxes are perfect for outdoor enthusiasts as they provide secure storage for items such as camping gear, hiking equipment, and sports gear. They also provide protection from the elements, ensuring your items stay dry and safe.
Repair and Replacement
Hard shell roof boxes are more durable and long-lasting than soft shell ones, but if they do need repair or replacement, it’s generally easier to find replacement parts or a new roof box. Soft shell roof boxes may be more difficult to repair or replace.
Benefits for Families with Children and Pets
Hard shell roof boxes are great for families with children and pets as they provide extra storage space for items such as strollers and pet carriers. They also provide a safe and secure place to store your items during transport.
Mounting System
Hard shell roof boxes come with a mounting system that is easy to install and provides a secure attachment to your vehicle’s roof rails. Soft shell roof boxes may require additional securing measures and may not be as secure.
Noise Level
Hard shell roof boxes are generally quieter than soft shell ones as they are more aerodynamic and create less wind resistance. Soft shell roof boxes may create more noise and wind resistance, which can be a nuisance on the road.
Benefits for Businesses
Hard shell roof boxes are great for businesses as they provide extra storage space for items such as tools, equipment, and merchandise. They also provide a secure place to store your items during transport, ensuring they arrive at their destination safely.
Environmental Impact and Mitigation
It’s important to consider the environmental impact of using a roof box. Hard shell roof boxes are generally more durable and long-lasting, which reduces waste and the need for frequent replacement. Soft shell roof boxes may not be as durable and may need to be replaced more frequently, which can increase waste.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while both hard shell and soft shell roof boxes have their own set of benefits, hard shell roof boxes are generally a better choice for those looking for durability, security, and a wider range of options. They offer more storage space, better weight distribution, and improved safety on the road.
FAQs
1. How do I know if a hard shell roof box will fit my vehicle?
You should measure your vehicle’s roof and the roof box before making a buying decision. Hard shell roof boxes are available in a wider range of sizes, ensuring a better fit for your vehicle.
2. How do I install a hard shell roof box?
Hard shell roof boxes typically come with a mounting system that can be easily attached to your vehicle’s roof rails.
3. How do I pack my roof box properly?
It’s important to distribute the weight evenly and to secure your items tightly. Hard shell roof boxes provide more secure packing options.
4. What’s the difference between a hard shell and a soft shell roof box?
Hard shell roof boxes are made of durable materials such as fiberglass or ABS plastic, while soft shell roof boxes are made of fabric such as PVC or nylon.
5. Are roof boxes legal and what are the restrictions?
It’s important to check the legality and restrictions in your area before purchasing a roof box. Hard shell roof boxes are generally more compliant with regulations as they are more securely attached to your vehicle’s roof.
